민사판례연구 46

민사판례연구회

저자:민사판례연구회

법률행위의당사자확정<박수곤>1
부동산에의부합의기준에관한시론<유형웅>51
적정대지지분권자,부족대지지분권자,구분소유자아닌대지공유자간법률관계에대한고찰<김동호>101
손해배상액의예정과위약벌:감액가능성을중심으로<유제민>151
가등기상권리를양도한최초의가등기명의인을상대로한사해행위취소및원상회복청구에서가액배상의범위<서정원>209
중첩된가액배상판결과민법제407조-대법원2022.8.11.선고2018다202774판결에관하여<김진하>249
신탁된주택을위탁자로부터임차한임차인의법적지위<곽희경>293
일의완성전도급인의해제권과도급계약해제의사표시의해석<구하경>337
임치계약해지에따른임치물반환청구권의소멸시효기산점<김찬영>379
종합통장자동대출예금계좌로의착오송금에따른법률관계와부당이득반환의무<고범진>425
무효인계약에기하여급부가이루어진경우,부당이득반환의범위와현존이익추정의번복<현재언>459
가해법인및피해법인에공통된사실상대표자의불법행위로인한법인의손해배상책임인정여부<송호영>499
의사결정능력있는미성년자환자에대한의사의설명의무-대법원2023.3.9.선고2020다218925판결을중심으로-<박혜진>537
간접강제결정에대한청구이의의소<구태회>591
담보권실행경매의공신력규정에관한해석의한계<강지웅>635
가상자산의증권성판단기준<이정수>685
주식양도제한약정의효력및그약정에위반한주식양도행위에따른법률관계<안태준>721
신주인수권부사채전환사채발행이후신주의발행과신주발행무효의소의제기가부<최문희>773
공법과사법이교차하는영역에서의법적혼란과그해결방안의모색-사회복지법인의기본재산처분허가의법적성격과소급적인취소가부에관하여<민성철>825
<附錄>資本市場의法的爭點및새로운動向
◇附錄에부치는말889
암호자산의개념및법적성격<김준영>891
블록체인기반가상자산에대한민사법적취급-기술적분석을기초로<신지혜>939
온라인금융거래와금융소비자보호<김정연>983
금융거래에서지급결제당사자의사법상권리·의무<김형석>1033
자본시장에서공시의무위반및불공정거래시의손해배상액산정기준-판례동향을중심으로-<임기환>1115

◇民事判例硏究會日誌1147
◇民事判例硏究會2023年度會務日誌1151
◇民事判例硏究會2025年度新入會員募集案內1154
◇民事判例硏究會定款1155
◇民事判例硏究간행규정1161
◇民事判例硏究會會員名單1163
Contents
CaseComments
DeterminationofPartiestoLegalActs1
AnEssayontheCriteriaforAttachmenttoImmovables51
AStudyonLegalRelationsAmongSectionalOwnersoftheCondominiumBuildingPossessinganAppropriateLandShare,SectionalOwnersPossessingLessThananAppropriateLandShare,andLandShareholdersWhoarenotSectionalOwners-SupremeCourtenbancDecision2017Da257067DecidedAugust25,2022101
LiquidatedDamagesandPenalty:FocusingontheReductionoftheAmount151
TheScopeofMonetaryCompensationintheRevocationandRestorationClaimofaFraudulentTransfer,inaCaseWheretheProvisionalRegistrationwasCompletedbyaFraudulentActandTransferredtoaThirdParty209
ConcurrentJudgementsontheRighttoClaimMonetaryCompensationandtheApplicationofArticle407oftheKoreanCivilAct-SupremeCourtDecision2018Da202774DecidedAugust11,2022249
LegalStatusoftheLesseewhoLeasestheTrustedHousefromtheTrustor-SuprememCourtCase2022.2.17.2019Da300095,300101-293
RightofRescissionofPersonWhoOrderedWorkBeforeitsCompletionandInterpretationofDeclarationofIntentiontoRescindaContractforWork337
StartingPointoftheStatuteofLimitationsfortheRighttoClaimReturnoftheBailedObjectUponTerminationoftheBailmentContract379
LegalRelationofErroneousRemittancetoanAutomaticBankAccountLoanandObligationtoReturnUnjustEnrichment425
WhentheContractisNull:Reversalof‘Still-ExistingPresumptionRule’andtheAmountofBenefitstobeReturned459
WhethertheLegalEntityisRecognizedasLiableforDamagesDuetotheIllegalActsofItsDeFactoRepresentativeCommontotheOffendingEntityandtheDamagedEntity499
DutytoExplaintoaPatientwhoisaMinorwithaDecision-MakingCapacity-ReviewontheSupremeCourtDecision2020Da218925DeliveredonMarch9,2023537
ObjectionSuitAgainstExecutionofIndirectCompulsoryEnforcementOrder591
DieGrenzenderAuslegungderBestimmungdesoffentlichenGlaubensderZwangsversteigerungfurdieVerfolgungdesRechtsausderHypothek-vorliegendeStreitsache:ObersterGerichtshofGroßerSenat,Urteilvom25.8.2022.-2018Da205209635
JudgementonaCharacteristicofSecuritiesforVirtualAssets-SeoulSouthernDistrictCourt2019Gadan225099,March25,2020-685
TheValidityoftheAgreementtoRestrictTransferofSharesandtheLegalRelationsSurroundingtheTransferofSharesViolatingtheAgreementFocusingonSupremeCourtDecision2019Da274639DecidedMarch31,2022721
SuitforInvalidatingNewSharesIssuedviaExerciseofConversionRightorWarrant773
AProposaltoAddressLegalUncertaintiesArisingFromtheIntersectionofPublicandPrivateLaws:RetrospectiveRevocationofthePermitforaSocialWelfareCorporationtoDisposeofitsFundamentalAssets?825

Articles
TheConceptandLegalNatureofCryptoasset891
CivilLegalTreatmentofBlockchain-BasedVirtualAssetsBasedontechnicalanalysis939
FinancialConsumerProtectioninDigitalAge983
LegalMechanismofCashlessPayment1033
TrendsofSupremeCourtDecisionAboutCalculatingtheAmountofDamagesinFalseStatementinaBusinessReportorUnfairTradinginCapitalMarkets1115

머리말

지난2023년에도법학계및법조계내·외적으로여러가지일이많았습니다.그럼에도민사판례연구회는이전과마찬가지로본연의임무인판례연구및토론을계속하여왔고,그결과물을모아민사판례연구제46권을내게되었습니다.
이번에도예년과마찬가지로10번의월례회에서발표된논문들과하계심포지엄에서발표된글들을모았습니다.이렇게활발히연구활동을하고또그가시적인성과물을발간할수있는것에깊이감사드립니다.
2박3일일정으로평창에서진행된2023년하계심포지엄에서는“자본시장의법적쟁점및새로운동향”을대주제로삼았습니다.암호자산·가상자산의개념과민사법적취급,온라인금융거래와금융소비자보호,지급결제당사자의사법상권리·의무,자본시장법위반관련손해배상액산정기준등최근에새롭게등장하거나그동안자세히살펴보지못했던쟁점들을다수다루었습니다.그결과를담은제46권은향후학계의귀중한자산이되리라믿습니다.
올해하계심포지엄의대주제는“소송대리의제문제”입니다.근년에우리나라에서도소송대리인의비닉특권,법률사무에서의AI활용등소송대리에관한중요한쟁점들이논의되고그중요성이커져가고있음에도불구하고,실체법에비해연구가충실히이루어지지않는것으로보입니다.이번하계심포지엄을통해소송대리및소송법에관한새로운법적쟁점을발굴하고이에관하여심층적으로토론함으로써,향후법학계와실무계의활발한논의를위한새로운전기가마련되었으면하는바람입니다.
마지막으로발간을위하여애써주신조인영교수님,이재찬판사님,그리고번거로운출판작업을맡아주신박영사의여러분께도감사의뜻을전합니다.

2024년2월
민사판례연구회회장전원열